PROBLEMS OF THE LAW ENFORCEMENT PRACTICE OF COURTS OF GENERAL JURISDICTION, WHICH ARISE WHEN CONSIDERING THE CONCLUSIONS SET OUT IN THE DECISIONS OF THE SUPREME COURT, AS WELL AS THE MODEL THEIR RESOLUTION

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2024/1.127-11

Keywords:

conclusion of the Supreme Court, similarity of legal relations, deviation from legal conclusion, defectiveness of conclusions, problems of taking into account conclusions

Abstract

Background. In accordance with the norms of national legislation, the conclusions of the Supreme Court regarding the application of certain norms of law must be taken into account by courts of general jurisdiction when applying such norms of law. Thus, the article addresses the theoretical and legal analysis of the institution of legal opinion of the Supreme Court as a unique act of law enforcement in the national judicial system.

Methods. The empirical scientific method (observation) was used in the part of the study of the practice of taking into account conclusions from the Supreme Court decisions by the courts; theoretical and scientific methods (proposing hypotheses and theories, analysis, synthesis, abstraction) in the part of identifying categories of improper (defective) consideration of conclusions from the Supreme Court decisions. The method of scientific modeling is used in the part of determining ways to solve the problematic issues raised in the article.

Results. Emphasis is placed on the problem of the insufficiency of the definitions in relation to legal regulation of the legal opinion of the Supreme Court. The article highlights problematic issues related to taking into account the conclusions from the decisions of the Supreme Court: 1) the problem of dividing such conclusions into those that directly affect the outcome of the proceedings, and those that do not have such an impact on the outcome; 2) the problem of taking into account the conclusions expressed without due consideration of the actual circumstances and/or legislation; 3) the problem of the defectiveness of conclusions relating to legal prescriptions that have lost their validity or have been changed, and conclusions from which the Supreme Court deviated; 4) the problem of taking into account conclusions from Supreme Court decisions retrospectively (backward in time). The analysis of the indicated problems was carried out on the basis of theoretical provisions, court practice and partially foreign experience of law enforcement.

Conclusions. Based on the practice of courts of general jurisdiction, the practice of the Supreme Court on the above-mentioned problems, attention is focused on cases of formal consideration of conclusions from Supreme Court decisions, own conclusions are put forward and models for solving problematic issues are proposed.

References

Administrative Judicial Code of Ukraine. Bulletin of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (VVR), 2005. No 35–36, No 37, Art. 446. Official portal of the VRU. [in Ukrainian]. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2747-15#Text

Bondarenko, E. I. (2021). Legal precedent in modern legal systems of the world. Qualifying scientific work on manuscript rights. [Dissertation for obtaining the scientific degree of candidate of legal sciences, specialty 12.00.01 "Theory and history of the state and law; history of political and legal students". M. P. Drahomanov National Pedagogical University; Institute of State and Law named after V. M. Koretsky of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine] [in Ukrainian].

Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine. Bulletin of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (VVR), 2004, 40-41, 42, Art. 492. Official portal of the VRU [in Ukrainian]. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1618-15#Text

Conclusion No 11 of the Consultative Council of European Judges to the attention of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on the quality of judicial decisions. (2008) [in Ukrainian]. https://wcd.coe.int/wcd/ViewDoc.jsp? Ref=CCJE(2008)OP11&Language=lanEnglish&Ver=original&Site=COE&Back ColorInternet=FEF2E0&BackColorIntranet=FEF2E0&BackColorLogged=c3c3c3

Conclusion No 20 of the Consultative Council of European Judges to the attention of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on the role of courts in ensuring the unity of the application of the law. (2017) [in Ukrainian]. https://rm.coe.int/ccje- opinion-no-20-2017-ukr/1680a54ba1

Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine. Information of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (VVR), 2013. No 9-10, No 11-12, No 13, Art. 88. Official portal of the VRU [in Ukrainian]. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/4651-17#Text

Economic Procedure Code of Ukraine. Information of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (VVR), 1992. No 6, Art. 56. Official portal of the VRU [in Ukrainian]. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1798-12#Text

Gudyma, D. A. (2020). What legal relations are similar? (Regarding the application of certain norms of procedural law). Materials of the presentation of the speech at the online conference "Ensuring the unity of judicial practice: legal positions of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court and standards of the Council of Europe" [in Ukrainian]. https://supreme.court.gov.ua/ userfiles/media/new_folder_for_uploads/supreme/Prezent_Gudima_podibni_pravovidn.pdf

Krat, V. I. Effective methods of protection: quo vadis?!. Materials of the speech presentation, March 31, 2023. Supreme Court [in Ukrainian]. https://supreme.court.gov.ua/userfiles/media/new_folder_for_uploads/supreme/2023_prezent/Prezentacia_efektivnist_31_03_2023.pdf

Parkhomenko, N. (2020). Unity of judicial practice as a component of legal regulation. Journal of the Kyiv University of Law, 1(3), 26–30 [in Ukrainian].

Pilkov, K. (2023). Conclusions of the Supreme Court: the formula of the conclusion, its obligation and the mechanism of withdrawal. Legal Scientific Electronic Journal, 8, 201–209 [in Ukrainian].

Resolution dated 03.07.2019 in case No 9901/939/18. Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court. Law Online [in Ukrainian]. https://zakononline.com.ua/ court-decisions/show/82998288 Resolution dated 03/27/2020 in case No 910/4450/19. Supreme Court. Cassation Commercial Court. Legal portal League Law [in Ukrainian]. https://verdictum.ligazakon.net/document/88556077

Resolution dated 04/07/2020 in case No 904/3657/18. Supreme Court. Great Chamber. Legal portal League Law [in Ukrainian]. https://verdictum.ligazakon.net/ document/89819806

Resolution dated 04/11/2022 in case No 522/22473/15-ts. Supreme Court. Cassation Commercial Court. Legal portal Liga Zakon [in Ukrainian]. https://verdictum.ligazakon.net/document/103922218

Resolution dated 04/13/2023 of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court in criminal case No 761/13685/14-k. Iplex database [in Ukrainian]. http://iplex.com.ua/doc.php?regnum=110308826&red=100003baaa2919f55c16d162b079a74a8d368f&d=5

Resolution dated 12.10.2021 in case No 233/2021/19. Supreme Court. Great Chamber. Legal portal Liga Zakon [in Ukrainian]. https://verdictum.ligazakon.net/document/101829987

Resolution dated February 22, 2021 in case No 754/7061/15. Supreme Court. Cassation Criminal Court. Legal portal Liga Zakon [in Ukrainian]. https://verdictum.ligazakon.net/document/95139651

Resolution dated February 22, 2023 in case No 280/11599/21. Supreme Court. Unified State Register Of Court Decisions [in Ukrainian]. https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/109138483

Resolution dated October 8, 2019 in case No 916/2084/17. Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court. Law Online [in Ukrainian]. https://zakononline.com.ua/court-decisions/show/84911545

Resolution dated September 1, 2020 in case No 216/3521/16-ts. Supreme Court. Great Chamber. Legal portal Liga Zakon [in Ukrainian]. https://verdictum.ligazakon.net/document/91644731

Resolution dated September 4, 2018 in case No 823/2042/16. Supreme Court. Great Chamber. Legal portal League Law [in Ukrainian]. https://verdictum.ligazakon.net/document/77969515

Serdyuk, V., & Babii, A. (2021). Legal opinion of the court of cassation as a tool for ensuring the stability and unity of judicial practice. Judicial and legal newspaper [in Ukrainian]. https://sud.ua/ru/news/blog/195911-pravoviy-visnovok-kasatsiynogo-sudu-yak-instrument-zabezpechennya-stalosti-ta-yednosti-sudovoyi-praktiki

Shumylo, M. (2020). Legal conclusions of the court of cassation: inter praeteritum et futurum. Entrepreneurship, economy and law, 12, 47–54 [in Ukrainian].

The Law of Ukraine On the Judiciary and the Status of Judges. Bulletin of the Verkhovna Rada (Verkhovna Rada), 2016. No 31, Art. 545. Official portal of the VRU [in Ukrainian]. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1402-19#Text

Published

07.11.2024

Issue

Section

Types of publication

How to Cite

PROBLEMS OF THE LAW ENFORCEMENT PRACTICE OF COURTS OF GENERAL JURISDICTION, WHICH ARISE WHEN CONSIDERING THE CONCLUSIONS SET OUT IN THE DECISIONS OF THE SUPREME COURT, AS WELL AS THE MODEL THEIR RESOLUTION. (2024). Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv. Legal Studies, 127(1), 70-76. https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2024/1.127-11

Most read articles by the same author(s)