LEGITIMACY AS A WORLDVIEW CRITERION FOR ASSESSING CONDUCT AND ACTIVITY

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2021/1.116-4

Abstract

The author analyzes the genesis of the ideas about the concept of "legitimacy". The focus is on analyzing different conceptual approaches to defining its content, essential characteristics and attributes, as well as the means of practicing legitimate conduct and activity. On the basis of the rule of law and natural legal understanding, the concept of the content of the category "legitimacy" is proposed. Attention is drawn to the contradictory provisions of the Constitution of Ukraine, which become evident in its true understanding. In particular, the author draws attention to the fact that the genesis of the formation of representations of legitimate conduct leads to the conclusion that initially it was interpreted solely from the standpoint of positivist understanding, which led to the conclusion that the main criterion for its legitimacy is its consistency only with the rules of law. Subsequently, the basic principles of the law began to be recognized as a component of its requirements. And nowadays, the concept according to which the conduct that meets the requirements of not only the provisions of the positive law but also the requirements of other generally recognized social norms that reflect the highest social values is gaining support. At the same time, while paying tribute to the progressive trends that are followed in these approaches, it should be acknowledged that they continue to be based on a positivist understanding in which the concept of "rule" is equated with the law and its form with its content. With regard to true understanding of the category of "legitimacy", when defining it, it is necessary to proceed from the fact that Ukraine's constitutional recognition of a person, his rights and freedoms as the highest value and the rule of law is the legal basis for the conclusion about the actual transformation of its legal system from traditional positivist legal understanding into natural-legal, according to which the law recognizes not the rules established by the state in the form of law, but human rights and freedoms, the content of which is its powers to own, use and order social values. And with this in mind, it becomes apparent that the concept of "legitimacy" means compliance with the requirements arising from the rights and freedoms of the subjects of the social relations. And since the social norms of conduct are always preceded, this creates the preconditions for a proper assessment of them for compliance with their requirements. As a consequence, in such circumstances, the principle of legality becomes part of the principle of legitimacy, but only if the law is legal. The main requirements of legitimacy include the rule of law, i.e. the priority of the human rights and freedoms in all the spheres of the public life; their warranty; obligation of their observance by all the participants of legal relations; effective and consistent counteracting; the inevitability of liability for the offense. As for the conditions of the law and order, the principles of the rule of law and, consequently, the legitimacy of conduct and activity, they are the corresponding guarantees, that is, the conditions, means and measures by which they are ensured, in particular: economic, ideological, political, legal, public and international. As for practical ways to ensure the rule of law, law and order and the legitimacy of conduct and activity, they are: persuasion, encouragement, coercive measures, prophylactic activity.

References

1. Котюк О. І. Правомірність слідчих дій: умови визначення та засоби забезпечення : дис. … канд. юрид. наук: спец. 12.00.01 / О. І. Котюк. – К. : Київ. нац. ун-т імені Тараса Шевченка, 2013.

2. Свириденко Г. В. Правомірна поведінка: сучасний контекст: монографія / Г. В. Свириденко. – К. : Вид-во "Юрид. думка", 2018.

3. Великий тлумачний словник української мови / Уклад. і гол. ред. В. Г. Бусел. – К. ; Ірпінь : Перун, 2005. – С. 1101.

4. Дробязко С. Г. Общая теория права : учеб. пособие / С. Г. Дробязко, В. С. Козлов. – Минск : Амалфея, 2005.

5. Пелевина М. С. Правомерное поведение – основа современного правового государства / М. С. Пелевина // Юрид. мысль. – 2014. – № 6 (86). – С. 25–28.

6. Погребняк С. П. Основоположні принципи права (змістовна характеристика) : монографія / С. П. Погребняк. – Х. : Право, 2008.

7. Черданцев А. Ф. Толкование права и договора : учеб. пособие / А. Ф. Черданцев. – М. : ЮНИТИ-ДАНА, 2003.

8. Методологические и теоретические проблемы государства и права развитого социализма / О. Э. Лейст и др. ; под ред. А. И. Денисова, О. Е. Кутафина. – М. : Изд-во Моск. ун-та, 1983.

9. Казаков В. Н. Правосознание и правомерное поведение : монографія / В. Н. Казаков, В. П. Малахов. – М. : Мос. ун-т МВД РФ им. В. Я. Кикотя, 2002.

10. Рабінович П. М. Формування основ правового світогляду, правової свідомості та правової культури шкільної молоді (теоретико- й соціально-правове дослідження) / Праці Львівської лабораторії прав людини і громадянина НДІ держ. будівництва та місц. самовр. НАПрН України / П. М. Рабінович, Т. В. Бачинський. Серія 1. – Л. : Вид-во ЛОБФ "Медицина і право", 2015. – Вип. 29. – С. 35–46.

11. Романова А. Правомірна поведінка як умова самоствердження людини / А. Романова // Юрид. вісник. – 2014. – № 6. – С. 91–95.

12. Головатий С. Верховенство права : у 3 кн. / С. Головатий. – К. : Фенікс, 2006. – Кн. 3.

13. Шпенглер О. Закат Европы. Очерки морфологии мировой истории / О. Шпенглер ; пер. с нем. И. Маханькова. – М. : Мысль, 1998. – Т. 2.

14. Гусарєв С. Д. Юридична діяльність: методологічні та теоретичні аспекти / С. Д. Гусарєв. – К. : Знання, 2005. – С. 106–120.

15. Конституція України [Електронний ресурс]. – Режим доступу : http://zakon0.rada.gov.ua/laws/show / 254к-вр

Published

19.03.2021

How to Cite

LEGITIMACY AS A WORLDVIEW CRITERION FOR ASSESSING CONDUCT AND ACTIVITY. (2021). Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv. Legal Studies, 116(1), 19-23. https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2021/1.116-4

Most read articles by the same author(s)