Italy: No Country for Arbitrators?

Authors

  • E. Silvestri Університет Павії

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2020/1.112-9

Abstract

The title of my presentation, besides being a play on the title of the Coen brothers film1 , makes it clear that Italy is not exactly the most hospitable environment when it comes to the popularity of arbitration. It is true that statistical data, when available, concern essentially institutional arbitration2 [1; 7, р. 39] (the empirical data are not really updated. The only comprehensive survey of ADR in Italy concerns 2016; in that year the total number of arbitration procedures carried out by private and public institutions was 708 (784 in 2015) and can be considered misleading, at least to a certain degree, since nothing is officially known of the phenomenon of ad hoc arbitration, which, apparently, is very popular but escapes survey. In any event, my purpose here is to sketch out some of the reasons why arbitration is still an elitist method for resolving disputes, in general – as we will see – commercial disputes.

References

1. Bonsignore V. La ricerca Isdaci sulla diffusione della giustizia alternativa in Italia nel 2016' in ISDACI-Istituto per l'arbitrato, la mediazione e il diritto commerciale. Decimo rapporto sulla diffusione della giustizia alternativa in Italia. ISDACI 2018. 7. 39.

2. Arbitrato CAM: le statistiche 2017. URL: https://www.camera-arbitrale.it/it/news/arbitrato-cam-le-statistiche-2017.php?id=810> accessed 25 November 2019.

3. Silvestri E. 'Too Much of a Good Thing: Alternative Dispute Resolution in Italy' (2017) 21 Netherlands-Vlaams Tijschriftvoor Mediation en Conflict management. 29.

4. 'Arbitrato CAM: le statistiche 2017', supra note 3.

5. Alpa G. Arbitration and ADR Reforms in Italy. 2018. 29 European Business Law Review 313.

6. Milone N. Arbitration: The Italian Perspective and the Finality of the Award. 2011. 1 Oñati Socio-Legal Series <https://ssrn.com/abstract=1986040> accessed 25 November 2019.

7. Draetta U. Italy as a Place for International Arbitrations: The Myths of the Italian Torpedo, the Irritual Arbitration et Alia. International Business Law Journal. 2013. 159.

8. Giovannini T. and Renna V. The Italian Experience Of Arbitration And The Arbitration Rules Of The Chamber Of Arbitration Of Milan: A Parallel View. 2010. URL: https://www.camera-arbitrale.it/Documenti/giovannini-renna_2010_ita_experience_arbitration.pdf (accessed 25 November 2019).

Published

20.05.2020

How to Cite

Italy: No Country for Arbitrators?. (2020). Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv. Legal Studies, 112(1), 49-51. https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2020/1.112-9