MAIN APPROACHES TO EFFECTIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2020/3.114-11Abstract
The topic of effective dispute resolution has been explored, as various conflicts are an integral part of public life or, as scholars rightly point out, conflicts are inevitable. The approaches used to resolve them are diverse and characterize the evolution of justice – from traditional litigation to modern alternative conciliation procedures and the so-called "conflict management", which helps not only to resolve disputes but also to maintain normal and productive relations between its participants in future. Alternative dispute resolution can be seen as a reaction to the significant increase in the number of appeals to court, the increase in court costs and the increase in court hearings, which inevitably accompany this form of protection of rights during the twentieth century. The first studies of alternative dispute resolution procedures can be found in the 1940s, but the interest of researchers increased significantly in the 1960s and 1970s, which led to the implementation of the concept of out-of-court protection in many countries, but not to dispute resolution. The basic modern approach to dispute resolution is characterized as a constructive dialogue for finding a compromise by any means, based on the vision of conflict as an integral and inevitable phenomenon that accompanies the dynamics of human relations. A change in the perception of the conflict should lead to a change in the established tools for their settlement into a comprehensive system that allows not so much to resolve it as to control, thus endowing it with constructive features that generally contribute to the development of productive relations. Accordingly, referring to our chosen epigraph, the vision of disputes as a basis for battle will grow into an awareness of their usefulness, if they are settled and controlled by experts.
References
1. Ury W. L. Designing an Effective Dispute Resolution System [notes] / W. L. Ury, J. M. Brett, S. B. Goldberg // In Practice Negotiation Journal. – Vol. 4. – Issue 4 (October 1988). – Р. 414.
2. Hepner A. W. Local and Unofficial Arrangements for Labor Dispute Settlement [article] / A. W. Hepner // Labor Dispute Settlement Law and Contemporary Problems. – Vol. 12. – Issue 2 (Spring 1947). – Р. 220–231.
3. Isaacs N. Two Views of Commercial Arbitration / N. Isaacs // Harvard Law Review. – 1927. – Vol. 40. – Issue 7. – P. 929–942.
4. Roth F. L. Arbitration – A Vital Tool for Lawyers [article] / F. L. Roth // Connecticut Bar Journal. – Vol. 21. – Issue 5 (December 1947). – P. 455–466.
5. Stern J. L. Alternative Dispute Settlement Procedures. Commentary / James L. Stern // Wisconsin Law Review. – Vol. 1968. – Issue 4. – P. 1100–1112.
6. Kovarsky I. Alternative Solutions to the Jurisdictional Dispute Problem / І. Kovarsky // Wayne Law Review. – Vol. 7. – Issue 2 (Winter 1960). – P. 295–334.
7. Aubert V. Courts and conflict resolution / V. Aubert // Journal of Conflict Resolution. – Vol. 11. – Issue 1 (March 1967). – P. 40–51.
8. Getman J. G. Labor Arbitration and Dispute Resolutionю Dispute Resolution / J. G. Getman. – Yale Law Journal. – Vol. 88. – Issue 5 (April 1979). – P. 916–949.
9. Dispute Resolution [comments] Dispute Resolution: Introduction // Yale Law Journal. – Vol. 88. – Issue 5 (April 1979). – P. 905–909.
10. Lubman S. Mao and Mediation: Politics and Dispute Resolution in Communist China [article] / S. Lubman // Californial Law Review. – Vol. 55. – Issue 5 (November 1967). – P. 1284–1360.
11. Притика Ю. Д. Посередництво як нова форма вирішення приватноправових спорів / Ю. Д. Притика // Вісник господарського судочинства. – 2006. – С. 264.
12. Comission Staff Working Paper Impact Assessment Accompanying the document Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on Alternative Dispute Resolution for consumer disputes (Directive on consumer ADR) and Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on Online Dispute Resolution for consumer disputes (Regulation on consumer ODR). URL: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A32013L0011 (date of request 01.08.2020).
13. Program on Negotiation. URL: https://www.pon.harvard.edu/daily/dispute-resolution/what-are-the-three-basic-types-of-dispute-resolution-what-to-know-about-mediation-arbitration-and-litigation/ (date of request 01.09.2020).
14. Metin U. A. Compulsory mediation: an important change in the procedure for resolving the commercial disputes in Turkey / U. A. Metin. URL: https://www.ukpandi.com/fileadmin/uploads/uk-pi/Latest_Publications/2017/COMPULSORY_MEDIATION.pdf (01.09.2020).
15. Matteucci G. Mandatory Mediation, the Italian experience / G. Matteucci. DOI: 10.12957/redp.2015.19964. URL: https://e-justice.europa.eu/content_mediation_in_member_states-64-en.do
16. O'Leary T. F. The Andean Common Market and the Importance of Effective Dispute Resolution Procedures [article] / T. F. O'Leary // International Organization Review. International Tax & Business Lawyer. – Vol. 2. – Issue 1 (Winter 1984). – P. 101–128.
17. Seki H. S. Effective Dispute Resolution in United States-Japan Commercial Transactions [comments] / H. S. Seki // Perspectives Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business. – Vol. 6. – Issue 4 (Winter 1984–1985). – P. 979–1009.
18. Cook J. A Quest for Justice: Effective and Efficient Alternative Dispute Resolution Processes [article] / J. Cook // Open Forum: Reforms in the Law Detroit College of Law Review. – Vol. 1983. – Issue 4 (Winter 1983). – P. 1129–1136.
19. Hall J. Negotiation: Dispute Resolution As an Effective Alternative to Trial / J. Hall // Commentary American Journal of Trial Advocacy. – Vol. 6. – Issue 3 (Spring 1983). – P. 481–484.
20. Gessford J. B. Arbitration of Professional Athletes' Contracts: An Effective System of Dispute Resolution in Professional Sports [notes] / J. B. Gessford // Note Nebraska Law Review. – Vol. 55. – Issue 2 (1976). – P. 362–382,
21. Whitelaw B. W. Health Care Arbitration in Michigan: An Effective Method of Alternative Dispute Resolution // B. W. Whitelaw // Michigan Bar Journal. – Vol. 72. – Issue 11 (November 1993). – P. 1158–1162,
22. Byrne C. New Horizons –Trends Influencing Effective Projects and Construction Dispute Resolution in Ireland [article] / C. Byrne, J. Heneghan // Construction Law International. – Vol. 6. – Issue 2 (June 2011). – P. 9–14.
23. Stegner M. Online Dispute Resolution: The Future of Consumer Dispute Resolution [article] / M. Stegner // Section V: ADR Yearbook on International Arbitration. – Vol. 5. – 2017. – P. 347–360.
24. Rowe M. The Non-Union Complaint System at MIT: An-Upward Feedback Mediation Model / М. Rowe // Alternatives to the High Cost Litigation. – Issue 2(4). – Р. 10–18.
25. Ewing D.W. Justice on the Job / D. W. Ewing // Harvard Business School Press, 1989. – Issue 27.
26. Busch R. F. Designing Effective Conflict Management Systems / R. F. Busch // Colorado Lawyer. – Vol. 27. – Issue 9 (September 1998). – P. 63–68.
27. Conbere J. P. Theory Building for Conflict Management System Design [notes] / J. P. Conbere // Integrating Theory, Research, and Practice in Select Conflict Contexts. Conflict Resolution Quarterly. – Vol. 19. – Issue 2 (Winter 2001). – P. 215–236.
28. Constantino C. A. Designing Conflict Management Systems / C. A. Constantino // A Guide to Creation Productive and Health Organizations in The Future of Conflict Management Systems Conflict Resolution Quarterly 33 (Supplement 1), 1996. – P. 27–34.
29. Piche G. R. Conflict Management – Litigation in Perspective [editorial] / G. R. Piche // Colorado Lawyer. – Vol. 17. – Issue 1 (January 1988). – P. 11–18.
30. Cook J. A quest for justice: Effective and efficient alternative dispute resolution processes / J. Cook // Detroit ollege of Law Review. – 1983. – Р. 1129–1136.
31. ПриватБанк против Суркисов. URL: https://hromadske.ua/ru/posts/privatbank-protiv-surkisov-minyust-ne-planiruet-vzimat-milliardy-griven-s-banka (дата звернення 01.09.2020).
32. Effective Dispute Resolution; Review of Options for Dispute Resolution Mechanisms and Procedures // Global Environmental Law Annual. – 2003. – P. 155–188.
33. Lipsky D. B. The Future of Conflict Management Systems Conflict Resolution Quarterly 33 (Supplement 1) / D. B. Lipsky. – 2015. URL: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/crq.21133 (date of request 01.08.2020).
34. Rule C. Resolving consumer disputes / C. Rule. URL: http://colinrule.com/writing/acr2008.pdf (date of request 01.08.2020)
35. Katsh E. Digital Justice: Technology and the interner of Disputes / Е. Katsh, О. Rabinovich-Einy. URL: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3508311 (date of request 01.08.2020).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
