THE COOPERATION OF A JUDGE AND THE PARTIES IN THE CIVIL PROCEDURE IN EUROPEAN STATES: GENERAL APPROACHES
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2019/1.109-4Abstract
This paper studies the principles of good faith and the cooperation between judges and parties, which are considered as highly relevant in current civil procedural law. According to many scholars, a new approach to defining their roles allows to overcome the basic urgent problems of modern civil justice – duration, high costs and, to some extent, the complexity of the trial. At the same time, its implementation leads to a positive impact on ensuring the efficiency and access to justice, which are integral parts of the rule of law. The evolution of the idea of directing litigation to peaceful compromise of parties and settling their dispute, has become of tremendous importance since the middle of the last century and today is considered as one of the inherent features of modern litigation. The idea ofgood faith in participating in the process was much developed in the first codes of civil procedure in Europe, in particular, in Austrian Code of Civil Procedure of 1898 and in French Code of Civil Procedure of 1806. The national legal doctrine contains the reflection of F. Klein's research, in particular the loyal cooperation between a judge's and parties' ideas. Later the national legislation of most European states applied the abovementioned during the reforms. Within the ELI-Unidroit Project of European Rules of Civil Procedure the Working Group on Procedural Rights used the idea of court and parties cooperation as the main ground and proposed to joint responsibility introduce with the aim of fair and just trial and avoiding of the traditional problems of two procedure models (A. Uzelac). The provisions of civil procedural law of many states, in particular of Ukraine, have more fully realized the idea of inadmissibility of abusing the procedural rights, which are justly regarded as an element of the principle of cooperation of the court and the parties in civil proceedings.
References
1. Аболонин В.О. Принципи добросовесности и сотрудничества в "новом" гражданском процессе. Арбитражный и гражданский процесс. 2013. № 8. С. 2–8.
2. Ван Реє К. Case management у Європі: сучасні підходи до реалізації у цивільному судочинстві. Судова апеляція. 2018. № 3(52). С. 95–114.
3. Доступ до правосуддя: проміжна доповідь. 1995. Опубліковано Спеціальною моніторинговою місією ОБСЄ в Україні.
4. Доступ до правосуддя: фінальна доповідь. 1996. Опубліковано Спеціальною моніторинговою місією ОБСЄ в Україні.
5. Ізарова І.О. Європейська історична традиція цивільного процесу та перспективи його подальшого розвитку. Право і суспільство. 2015. № 4. С. 67–72.
6. Ізарова І., Вебрайте В., Флейшар Р. Case management в цивільному судочинстві: порівняльне дослідження законодавства Литви, Польщі й України. Право України. 2018. № 10. С. 129–146.
7. Ізарова І., Сільвестрі Е. Принцип case management в цивільному судочинстві: порівняльне дослідження законодавства Італії та України. Вісник Київського національного університету імені Тараса Шевченка. 2018. № 1(106). С. 19–23.
8. Іzarova Iryna, Korotenko Tetiana. Prevention of Procedural Rights Abuse. A New Experience of Ukrainian Judges in Polski Proces. Cywilny, No. 1/2019. P. 24–33.
9. Кофанов Л.Л. Lex и ius: возникновение и развитие в VIII–III вв. до н. э. Москва, 2006. С. 219–243.
10. Малюшин К.А. Принципы гражданского исполнительного права. Проблемы понятия и системы. Москва ; Берлин, 2011. С. 157.
11. Семенов В.М. Конституционние принципи гражданского судопроизводства. Москва, 1982, С. 99.
12. Узелац А. На шляху до Європейських правил цивільного процесу: переосмислення процесуальних обов'язків. Вісник Київського національного університету імені Тараса Шевченка. 2018. № 1(106). С. 23–32.
13. ALI/UNIDROIT. Принципи транскордонного цивільного процесу. 2005.
14. De la Commémoration d'un code à l'autre: 200 ans de procédure civile en France / ed. by L. Cadiet, G. Canivet. Paris, 2005. P. 111–170.
15. European Traditions in Civil Procedure / ed. by C. H. Van Rhee. Oxford, 2005. P. 25–26.
16. Rhee C. H. Van. Harmonization of Civil Procedure: An Historical and Comparative Perspective in Civil Litigation in a Globalizing World / ed. by C. H. Van Rhee, X. E. Kramer. The Hague, 2012. Р. 39–63.
17. Rhee Van C. H. Civil Litigation in Twentieth Century Europe. URL: http://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/tijvrec75&div=29&id=&page=.
18. Rhee Van C. H. Civil Procedure in Edgar Encyclopedia of Comparative Law / ed. by J. M. Smits. 2006. P. 120–134.
19. Uzelac Alan. Towards European Rules of Civil Procedure: Rethinking Procedural Obligations. Hungarian Journal of Legal Studies. 2017. № 1. Р. 3–18.
20. Van Caenegem R.C. History of European Civil Procedure. Encyclopedia of comparative law. Vol. XVI. Civil Procedure / ed. by M. Cappelletti. 1987. P. 53–57.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
