RELATIONSHIP OF CONCEPTS "LEGAL PROTECTION"AND "PROTECTION OF RIGHTS" IN SCIENTIFIC DISCOURSE

Authors

  • Yana Babych

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2021/4.119-2

Keywords:

legal protection, human rights, restoration of violated rights, prevention of offenses

Abstract

The article addresses the understanding of the legal categories "legal protection" and "protection of rights". The legal nature and content of these definitions are analyzed. Particular attention is paid to the characteristics of these definitions in scientific international and domestic doctrines. The positions of five different scientific schools on the understanding of these concepts are considered. The first cohort of scientists adheres to the views according to which such definitions are analyzed as interaction of whole and part. The second group of scholars identifies the concepts of "legal protection" and "protection of rights". The third point of view on the specified theoretical problems, consists of the delimitation of the outlined definitions. The fourth constellation of scholars reveals the analyzed categories through the prism of individual branches of law, taking into account the subject and method of legal regulation of each area. The universal approach distinguishes between the concepts of "legal protection" and "protection of rights" and considers them as different, but at the same time absolutely full-fledged legal categories. It is substantiated that the latter has normative and applied significance and is effectively used by the international community both at the doctrinal and legislative levels. On the basis of the conducted theoretical research the independent scientific conclusions and judgments on the analyzed subjects are offered, in particular the author's definition of definition "legal protection" is given. In addition, the main features inherent in the above categories are highlighted. Particular attention is paid to the need of highlighting the preventive component of the concept of "legal protection", which is particularly important within this category.

References

Bilodid I.K. (1972). Slovnyk ukrai'ns'koi' movy [Dictionary of the

Ukrainian language]. Kyi'v : Naukova Dumka.

2. Alekseev S.S. (1981). Obshhaja teoryja prava [General theory of

law]. T.1. M.: Jurydycheskaja lyteratura [Legal literature], 1981.

3. Zhelihovs'ka Ju.V. (2015). Spivvidnoshennja ta rozmezhuvannja

ponjat' "ohorona ta zahyst" [Correlation and delimitation of the concepts of

"protection and defense"]. Naukovyj visnyk mizhnarodnogo gumanitarnogo

universytetu. Serija: Jurysprudencija. [Scientific Bulletin of the International

Humanities University. Series: Jurisprudence]. № 13. Vol. 2. p.18-21.

4. Shumov P.V. (2013). Sootnoshenye ponjatyj "zashhyta" y "ohrana"

ynformacyonnyyh prav [The relationship between the concepts of

"protection" and "protection" of information rights]. Ugolovno-yspolnytel'naja

systema: pravo, ekonomyka, upravlenye [Penitentiary system: law,

economics, management]. № 5. p. 12-14.

5. Vavzhenchuk S. Ja. (2010) Spivvidnoshennja ponjat' "zahyst" ta

"ohorona" trudovyh prav v chynnomu zakonodavstvi [The ratio of the concepts of "protection" and " defense" of labor rights in current legislation].

Forum prava [Forum of law]. № 1. p. 45-49.

6. Parhomenko N. M. (2008) Dzherela prava: problemy teorii' ta

metodologii'. [Sources of law: problems of theory and methodology]. Instytut

derzhavy i prava im. V. M.Korec'kogo NAN Ukrai'ny [Institute of State and Law.

VM Koretsky NAS of Ukraine]. K.: Jurydychna dumka [Legal opinion], 335 p.

7. Sokolenko O. L. (2013) Zahyst prav gromadjan jak osnovna

funkcija pravovoi' derzhavy. [Protection of citizens' rights as the main

function of the rule of law]. Chasopys Kyi'vs'kogo universytetu prava

[Journal of Kyiv University of Law].№ 2. p. 118-121.

8. Pashuk T.I. (2006) Pravo ljudyny na efektyvnyj derzhavnyj zahyst

i'i' prav ta svobod : dys... kand. juryd. Nauk [The human right to effective

state protection of its rights and freedoms]: L'vivs'kyj nacional'nyj un-t im.

Ivana Franka [Ivan Franko National University of Lviv]. L., 2006.

9. Prytyka Ju. D. (2004) Ponjattja i dyferenciacija sposobiv i zahystu

cyvil'nyh prav ta interesiv [The concept and differentiation of methods and

protection of civil rights and interests]. Visnyk Kyi'vs'kogo nacional'nogo

universytetu imeni Tarasa Shevchenka [Bulletin of the Taras Shevchenko

National University of Kyiv].№ 60–62. p. 16–19.

10. Grygorchuk M. V. (2017) Zahyst prav ta ohoronjuvanyh zakonom

interesiv sub'jektiv gospodarjuvannja: material'nyj i procesual'nyj aspekty

[Protection of rights and legally protected interests of business entities:

material and procedural aspects]. Teorija i praktyka pravoznavstva [Theory

and practice of jurisprudence]. Issue. 1 (11). p. 1-13.

11. Abramov V.Y.(2007) Prava rebenka y yh zashhyta v Rossyy:

obshheteoretycheskyj analyz: dys. ... d-ra juryd. nauk [The rights of the child

and their protection in Russia: general theoretical analysis: dis. ... Dr. Jurid.

Science]:. Saratov. 455 p.

12. Tarhov V. A. (1997) Grazhdanskoe pravo: obshhaja chast' : kurs

lekcyj [Civil law: the general part: a course of lectures] / pod red.

V. A. Rybakova. – Cheboksary : Chuvashskoe knyzhnoe yzd-vo [Chuvash

Book Publishing House]. 331 p.

13. Mordovec A.S. (1996) Socyal'no-jurydycheskyj mehanyzm

obespechenyja prav cheloveka y grazhdanyna [Socio-legal mechanism for

ensuring human and civil rights]. Saratov.

14. Zubach I. M. (2014) Funkcija zahystu u suchasnomu kryminal'-

nomu provadzhenni Ukrai'ny [Function of protection in modern criminal

proceedings of Ukraine]. Visnyk Nacional'nogo universytetu "L'vivs'ka

politehnika". Jurydychni nauky [Bulletin of the National University "Lviv

Polytechnic". Legal sciences.]. № 810. p. 178–183.

15. Voloshanivs'ka T.V. (2016) Shhodo pytannja rozmezhuvannja

ponjat' "zahyst" ta "ohorona" u kryminal'nomu provadzhenni v svitli

mizhnarodnyh standartiv prav ljudyny [On the issue of distinguishing

between the concepts of "protection" and "defense" in criminal proceedings

in the light of international human rights standards]. Jurydychnyj naukovyj

elektronnyj zhurnal [Legal scientific electronic journal]. № 6. p. 216-220.

Published

27.10.2021

How to Cite

RELATIONSHIP OF CONCEPTS "LEGAL PROTECTION"AND "PROTECTION OF RIGHTS" IN SCIENTIFIC DISCOURSE. (2021). Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv. Legal Studies, 119(4), 8-11. https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2021/4.119-2